When All-Star or Pro Bowl categories in
Immaculate Grid are paired with a team, the player must have been an All-Star / Pro Bowler in a season that they appeared for that team. Any team that the player played for in the season that they were an All-Star / Pro Bowler will be accepted.
For example,
Jay Bruce played for the Reds and Mets in 2016, a season in which he was named an All-Star. Bruce will match for either Reds / All-Star or Mets / All-Star.
When All-Star or Pro Bowl is paired with a non-team category, it does not need to be in the same season.
For baseball, All-Star Games include the AL vs. NL All-Star Game and the Negro League East-West Games, while in Men's Basketball both NBA and ABA All-Star Games are included.
Full rules for these categories can be found by clicking the "Rules" link
above the game.